Current:Home > StocksOliver James Montgomery-I can't help but follow graphic images from Israel-Hamas war. I should know better. -Capitatum
Oliver James Montgomery-I can't help but follow graphic images from Israel-Hamas war. I should know better.
Benjamin Ashford View
Date:2025-04-06 08:36:29
Like many,Oliver James Montgomery I’ve recently been using social media to follow the war in the Middle East. As a habit, following news like this makes a certain amount of sense – social media has often been one of the better sources for breaking information on emerging crises.
Many aspects of this war are unique, but what is increasingly common is that my social media feeds, along with those of many others, are populated with extremely graphic images, many of which, having seen them, I fervently wished I could unsee. Yet I still felt compelled to follow the news, to seek out ever-more visceral videos and details of this unfolding human tragedy.
I am far from alone in my exposure to this extreme content. And while it may seem like being an active, informed citizen requires such immersion in raw imagery, I am also a social psychologist and should know better.
Immersive sensory experiences tied to secondary trauma
The effects of a traumatic event – and the events in Israel and Gaza are certainly that – are, as we psychologists well know, contagious. That is, their effects can spread well beyond their initial victims. In war, those victims include those who are displaced, injured and killed, as well as those who have lost a loved one.
The idea of secondary trauma recognizes that people indirectly exposed to an event like war can suffer as well.
Take, for example, drone operators, who endlessly scan live footage and take split second orders to fire rockets at suspected terrorists, then commute home in time for dinner. Even though they are not physically exposed to harm, these immersive sensory experiences become associated with real trauma.
Gaza humanitarian crisis:Israel-Hamas war will leave a generation in trauma. Will the world forget its children?
That jarring disconnect, especially because it often goes unacknowledged, becomes its own form of trauma for people in critical roles such as emergency rescuers, social media content moderators, law enforcement and intelligence analysts.
Secondary trauma was, for a long time, largely confined to people involved in the initial event, like first responders. Thanks to technology, however, it can now afflict anyone with a smartphone.
And now, as graphic images from Israel and Gaza proliferate on social media, it is likely that these images are having significant negative impacts on the mental health and well-being of many – especially adolescents and young adults, who already struggle mightily.
And social media choices help spread secondary trauma
The proliferation of traumatizing social media content is, make no mistake, a deliberate choice. People post war dispatches for many reasons, such as to expose atrocities, but also to deceive and to serve as propaganda. Hamas attackers have hijacked victims’ social media accounts to sow even more terror.
For their part, social media platforms have actively encouraged the spread of misinformation – this after layoffs shed their ability to weed it out.
Social media algorithms also drive people to extreme content, even when they're not actively looking for it.
The global mental health impacts of this war are only just beginning. But, like its casualties, they will likely be staggering. Social media companies could and should do more to moderate the virality of such content, but they have largely abdicated this responsibility.
Many have withdrawn from the business of providing news – that is, accurate and relevant information – leaving behind a toxic stew of false and misleading posts. Communities might need to seek out less toxic alternatives to the digital town square.
That mental health and health behaviors are contagious is both good and bad news. Parents should look to improve their own social media habits and model a healthy digital lifestyle for their kids. Digital health companies could also shift their focus from individual to public health.
Overwhelmed by the Israel-Hamas war?Here's how to protect your mental health.
Young people are in many ways their own best hope. Today’s youth are active and enthusiastic about shaping the world they will grow up in. Policymakers would do well to prioritize younger voices, concerns and ideas when thinking through proposals toward building a less traumatizing form of social media.
Trauma is often described as a shattering of one’s assumptions or worldviews. That is, when events collide with our expectations, beliefs or hopes, we are forced to reconsider what is truly possible.
This latest war – set in a world still emerging from the COVID-19 pandemic, grappling with social isolation and mental health crises – has provided plenty of traumatizing developments, with the grim promise of more to come. Mitigating their impact on global mental health might require some combination of regulations, “healthy” social networks or personal behavior change.
It certainly requires making hard choices and doing the work to forge community bonds that prioritize everyone’s well-being. And much of that work starts with knowing the spillover effects of trauma, and how it affects us all.
Douglas Yeung is a senior behavioral scientist at RAND Corporation and a member of the Pardee RAND Graduate School faculty.
veryGood! (63)
Related
- Apple iOS 18.2: What to know about top features, including Genmoji, AI updates
- Olivia Newton-John's daughter Chloe gets candid about her grief journey: 'I have been neglecting myself'
- Pakistani rescuers try to free 6 kids and 2 men in a cable car dangling hundreds of feet in the air
- Ecuador hit by earthquake and cyberattacks amid presidential election
- South Korea's acting president moves to reassure allies, calm markets after Yoon impeachment
- Jailed Sam Bankman-Fried can’t prepare for trial without vegan diet and adequate meds, lawyers say
- See the nearly 100-year-old miracle house that survived the Lahaina wildfire and now sits on a block of ash
- Ethiopia to investigate report of killings of hundreds of its nationals at the Saudi-Yemen border
- Questlove charts 50 years of SNL musical hits (and misses)
- Jennifer Aniston reveals she's 'so over' cancel culture: 'Is there no redemption?'
Ranking
- Tarte Shape Tape Concealer Sells Once Every 4 Seconds: Get 50% Off Before It's Gone
- Trader Joe's recalls vegan crackers because they could contain metal
- In his new book ‘The Fall,’ author Michael Wolff foresees the demise of Fox News
- Zendaya's New Hair Transformation Is Giving Rachel From Friends
- Sam Taylor
- Home sales slumped in July as rising mortgage rates and prices discouraged many would-be homebuyers
- Facebook users in US have until Friday to claim their piece of Meta's $725 million settlement
- Arrest made in death of 1-year-old girl left in hot van outside of Nebraska day care
Recommendation
New Mexico governor seeks funding to recycle fracking water, expand preschool, treat mental health
As cities struggle to house migrants, Biden administration resists proposals that officials say could help
Indianapolis woman charged with neglect in son’s accidental shooting death
850 people still unaccounted for after deadly Maui wildfires, mayor says
Louvre will undergo expansion and restoration project, Macron says
Feeling dizzy? It could be dehydration. Here's what to know.
Tropical Storm Harold path: When and where it's forecasted to hit Texas
Conditions are too dangerous to recover bodies of 2 men killed in Alaska plane crash, officials say