Current:Home > ContactRepublican effort to hold Attorney General Merrick Garland in inherent contempt of Congress falls short -Capitatum
Republican effort to hold Attorney General Merrick Garland in inherent contempt of Congress falls short
Rekubit View
Date:2025-04-06 20:25:51
Washington –– A Republican-led effort to hold Attorney General Merrick Garland in inherent contempt of Congress fell short on Thursday, without enough support among House Republicans for a resolution to impose a fine of $10,000 per day on Garland for defying a congressional subpoena.
In a 204 to 210 vote, four Republicans voted with all Democrats to oppose the measure.
Rep. Anna Paulina Luna, a Florida Republican, forced the vote, which she has been threatening in recent weeks, warning that if Garland didn't comply with a subpoena for the audio recording of an interview concerning President Biden's handling of classified documents, that she would move forward with the tool, which has rarely been used, especially in modern times.
Luna initially intended to bring up a resolution that could have resulted in Garland being taken into custody, but opted to move forward with the daily fine approach amid pushback from her GOP colleagues.
"In order for the House of Representatives to do its job, we must have access to the information that will allow us to make informed decisions on behalf of our constituents," Luna said on the the House floor on Wednesday. "We have been left with no choice but to rely on inherent contempt, our constitutional authority to hold an individual accountable for refusing to comply with congressional demands."
House Republicans are seeking audio recordings of the president's interview with special counsel Robert Hur, which came as part of an investigation that wrapped earlier this year. Though the House Judiciary and Oversight committees demanded that the Justice Department provide the tapes as part of their impeachment inquiry into the president, the president asserted executive privilege over the recordings in May. But that didn't prevent House Republicans from voting to hold Garland in contempt of Congress for the refusal to hand over the recordings in a vote last month.
Though the move to hold Garland in contempt marked an escalation, it was not without precedent. In 2012, former Attorney General Eric Holder was held in contempt, as was former attorney general Bill Barr in 2019. Neither faced criminal charges from their own Justice Departments.
Absent compliance, inherent contempt is one of three formal methods that Congress can use, according to a 2017 report from the Congressional Research Service. The report notes that the "long dormant" inherent contempt power allows Congress to detain and imprison an individual until they comply and "there may be an argument for the imposition of monetary fines as an alternative." The other avenues involve relying on the other branches of government to enforce subpoenas.
But the report outlines that there's no precedent for Congress imposing a fine in the contempt of Congress context. And a 2019 report from the Congressional Research Service notes that "even if Congress retains this authority, it is unclear how such a fine would be implemented and, in the case that the contemnor refuses to remit the sum, collected."
A spokesperson for the Justice Department told CBS News that the move is "unconstitutional."
"We are confident our arguments would prevail in court," the spokesperson said.
Democrats fiercely opposed the resolution, claiming Republicans are seeking the audio only so they may be used in attack ads against the president.
"This is a stupid resolution," Rep. Jim McGovern, a Massachusetts Democrat, said. "The attorney general turned over the exact transcripts of the interview that Republicans demanded, but that wasn't good enough… this is Republicans weaponizing the government to go after their political opponents."
Luna's privileged motion, which bypassed House leadership to get a vote on the floor, required that leadership schedule the vote within two legislative days. Speaker Mike Johnson indicated ahead of the vote that he would vote in favor of the resolution, though he said his preference would be to continue to seek relief through the courts.
"I'm for being as aggressive as possible with holding Merrick Garland accountable," Johnson said at a news conference on Tuesday.
House leadership has so far appeared inclined to pursue enforcement of the subpoena, especially since a disastrous debate performance by President Joe Biden prompted increased calls to gain access to the audio recording that likewise prompted alarm among Democrats about the president's fitness for another term earlier this year. The House Judiciary Committee filed a lawsuit earlier this month against the Justice Department to enforce the subpoena.
Former President Donald Trump came out in support of the measure on Wednesday, saying he agrees with the move to hold Garland in inherent contempt in a social media post. "Republicans MUST GET TOUGH about stopping weaponization and cheating," he wrote.
- In:
- Merrick Garland
- U.S. House of Representatives
Kaia Hubbard is a politics reporter for CBS News Digital, based in Washington, D.C.
TwitterveryGood! (184)
Related
- South Korea's acting president moves to reassure allies, calm markets after Yoon impeachment
- How IBM's gamble ushered in the computer age
- 'Our idol!': 92 year old's rim-to-rim Grand Canyon hike inspires throng of followers worldwide
- Wisconsin Republicans look to pass constitutional amendments on voter eligibility, elections grants
- The Best Stocking Stuffers Under $25
- Britney Spears says Madonna pulled her through dark times with 'strength I needed to see'
- Reno man convicted of arsons linked to pattern of domestic violence, police say
- Dwayne The Rock Johnson wants Paris museum to change the skin color of his new wax figure
- Buckingham Palace staff under investigation for 'bar brawl'
- Tensions boil as Israel-Hamas war rages. How do Jewish, Muslim Americans find common ground?
Ranking
- This was the average Social Security benefit in 2004, and here's what it is now
- See the wreckage from the 158-vehicle pileup near New Orleans; authorities blame 'superfog'
- Six under-the-radar NBA MVP candidates you need to keep an eye on in the 2023-24 season
- Jennifer Lopez's Intimissimi Lingerie Collection Will Have Jaws on the Floor
- Meta donates $1 million to Trump’s inauguration fund
- Bowl projections: Is College Football Playoff chaos ahead with six major unbeatens left?
- Four years after fire engulfed California scuba dive boat killing 34 people, captain’s trial begins
- Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce's Winning Date Nights Continue in Kansas City
Recommendation
Sam Taylor
Kansas City Chiefs WR Justyn Ross arrested on criminal damage charge, not given bond
Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources secretary resigning after 10 months on the job
Three men created a fake country to steal millions in COVID funds. Here's how they got caught.
DoorDash steps up driver ID checks after traffic safety complaints
Prosecutors close investigation of Berlin aquarium collapse as the cause remains unclear
California orders Cruise driverless cars off the roads because of safety concerns
Trump’s lawyers file challenges to Washington election subversion case, calling it unconstitutional