Current:Home > reviewsCritics slam posthumous Gabriel García Márquez book published by sons against his wishes -Capitatum
Critics slam posthumous Gabriel García Márquez book published by sons against his wishes
Robert Brown View
Date:2025-04-06 10:21:45
Gabriel García Márquez has a posthumous book coming out 10 years after his death. But he wouldn't have ́aMáwanted it that way.
García Márquez's final book "Until August" is set for release on March 12, but the author explicitly told his sons he didn't want the work published.
"He told me directly that the novel had to be destroyed," the author's younger son Gonzalo García Barcha told The New York Times. His eldest son, Rodrigo García, said his dad "lost the ability to judge the book."
In the New York Times piece, the brothers say they helped publish "Until August" because it lifts the veil on a new side to their father, who centered the book around a female protagonist for the first time. However, García told the outlet that he and his brother "were worried of course to be seen as simply greedy."
"Until August" follows a happily married woman Ana Magdalena Bach, who travels every August by a ferry to an island where her mom is buried to find another love for just one night.
Check out: USA TODAY's weekly Best-selling Booklist
García Márquez, one of the most popular Spanish-language writers ever, died in 2014 in Mexico City at the age of 87. His book "100 Years of Solitude" sold over 50 million copies, which is a mammoth feat in the literary world.
Author Gabriel García Márquez diesat 87
Oprah Winfrey chose his books twice for her original book club, "100 Years of Solitude" in 2004 and "Love in the Time of Cholera" in 2007, a rare occurrence for the media mogul.
It seems that his new work won't receive the same fate. Critics are slamming "Until August," which spans just 144 pages, in early reviews.
Harsh reviews for Gabriel García Márquez's new book: 'a faded souvenir'
"Until August" has yielded harsh reactions from several publications.
In a review of the book for British outlet i News, author Max Lui wrote, "The story ends so abruptly that it is obvious that it is unfinished" and called out the author's family and publishers for disrespecting his wishes.
"Usually, in a review of an underwhelming posthumous publication or minor work by a major author, it is worth saying that, despite its flaws, it will delight devoted fans. I do not believe that is true of 'Until August.' Márquez knew this and was right not to want it to see the light of day," Liu wrote.
Lucy Hughes-Hallett called the Latin American author's last novel was "not good writing" and "like a faded souvenir" for The Guardian.
"So should it have been published? There are small errors of continuity. The structure is ungainly. More importantly, the prose is often dismayingly banal, its syntax imprecise," she wrote.
While writer David Mills in a review for The Times agreed with similar critiques, he seemed to enjoy the book.
"Yet, for all these faults, 'Until August' is recognizably a Garcia Marquez novel: inventively enjoyable and working to its surprising, pleasing ending. I read it straight through in one sitting, then got up the next day and did it again," Mills wrote.
veryGood! (126)
Related
- Woman dies after Singapore family of 3 gets into accident in Taiwan
- West Point sued for using 'race-based admissions' by group behind Supreme Court lawsuit
- He's dressed Lady Gaga and Oprah. Now, designer Prabal Gurung wants to redefine Americana.
- Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis injects presidential politics into the COVID vaccine debate
- Juan Soto to be introduced by Mets at Citi Field after striking record $765 million, 15
- Amazon plans to hire 250,000 workers for holiday season. Target says it will add nearly 100,000
- Polish police briefly detain lawmaker who interrupted prime minister’s speech
- House Oversight Committee to hold first hearing of impeachment inquiry into President Biden on Sept. 28
- Toyota to invest $922 million to build a new paint facility at its Kentucky complex
- Colombia announces cease-fire with a group that split off from the FARC rebels
Ranking
- 'As foretold in the prophecy': Elon Musk and internet react as Tesla stock hits $420 all
- Michigan State football coach Tucker says `other motives’ behind his firing for alleged misconduct
- West Point sued over using race as an admissions factor in the wake of landmark Supreme Court ruling
- 'Slap in the face': West Maui set to reopen for tourism, with outrage from residents
- Working Well: When holidays present rude customers, taking breaks and the high road preserve peace
- Fantasy football rankings for Week 3: Running back depth already becoming a problem
- Asteroid that passes nearby could hit Earth in the future, NASA says
- Browns star Nick Chubb suffers another severe knee injury, expected to miss rest of NFL season
Recommendation
'No Good Deed': Who's the killer in the Netflix comedy? And will there be a Season 2?
Elon Musk suggests X will start charging all users small monthly payment
Oregon’s attorney general says she won’t seek reelection next year after serving 3 terms
Fantasy football rankings for Week 3: Running back depth already becoming a problem
Realtor group picks top 10 housing hot spots for 2025: Did your city make the list?
Thousands of mink let loose from fur farm in Pennsylvania
This is what it’s like to maintain the US nuclear arsenal
Mischa Barton Reflects on Healing and Changing 20 Years After The O.C.'s Premiere